How the IntimPicks Score Works

The IntimPicks Score is the rating out of 5 shown at the top of every review. This page explains the five pillars behind it, the grid we use to grade each one, and what the score does and does not claim.

In short: every review shows a breakdown across five weighted pillars, graded from published manufacturer data with the fixed grid below. Where a brand publishes no decibel figure, the acoustic pillar relies on a comparative editorial estimate, marked with an asterisk (*). The overall score is an editorial rating informed by these pillars, not their mechanical average. No brand pays for a review or a score.

The five pillars

Pillar Weight What we look at How it is graded (out of 5)
Acoustic discretion 25% The maximum noise level stated by the manufacturer 45 dB or less: 5 · up to 50 dB: 4.5 · up to 55 dB: 4 · up to 60 dB: 3.5 · up to 65 dB: 3 · above 65 dB: 2. Without a published figure, the editorial estimate applies: Discreet* 4, Audible* 3. Not applicable to devices without a motor.
Body-safe materials & hygiene 20% The materials listed by the manufacturer, non-porous surfaces and how easily the device can be cleaned Body-safe silicone only: 5 · body-safe silicone with ABS: 4.5 · silicone head on a body in another material: 4
Waterproofing 20% The water-resistance rating stated by the manufacturer IPX7: 5 · waterproof without a stated IP rating: 4 · splash-resistant (IPX4 to IPX6): 3 · not waterproof: 2
Battery & charging 20% The run time stated by the manufacturer for a full charge 4 h or more: 5 · 3 h or more: 4.5 · 2 h or more: 4 · 1.5 h or more: 3.5 · 1 h or more: 3. Not applicable to mains-powered devices, to devices that never need charging, or without a stated run time.
Ergonomics & controls 15% The documented control options and form 3.5, plus 0.5 for each of: optional app control; an adaptable or hands-free form (adjustable hinge, shape-holding or flexible body, wearable); an extra control mode (Autopilot, motion-sensing remote, long-distance control); a travel lock. Capped at 5.

Hygiene and care are part of the materials pillar: a non-porous, body-safe surface is what makes thorough cleaning possible, and every review details how to clean, dry and store the device. The five pillars therefore cover the six criteria described in our editorial standards.

How the overall score is set

The pillar grades and their weights frame our assessment, but the overall IntimPicks Score is an editorial rating, not their mechanical average. It also reflects what a fixed grid cannot capture: the documented design of each device, how its features compare with other devices in the same category, and its stated limits. A pillar that does not apply to a device, such as acoustics for a trainer without a motor, is left out rather than scored at zero.

Rankings use the overall score first. When two devices share the same score, the device with a lower stated noise level comes first, then the device with a stated IP rating.

Where the data comes from

Every grade comes from manufacturer product pages, user manuals and published documentation and, where a brand publishes nothing, from authorised retailer listings, which each review names. We do not run laboratory, acoustic or battery tests. Noise levels are the maximums stated by manufacturers. Where a brand publishes no decibel figure, the acoustic grade relies on a comparative editorial estimate based on comparable devices; it is marked with an asterisk (*) in the breakdown and explained in the review.

Independence

No brand pays for a review, a score or a ranking, and no sponsorship or commercial partnership influences a grade. Some links on IntimPicks are affiliate links that may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you; they never change a score. Read more in our affiliate disclosure.

Frequently asked questions

Is the IntimPicks Score the average of the five pillars?

No. The pillars are graded with a fixed, published grid, and their weights show how much each one counts in our assessment, but the overall score is an editorial rating that also reflects each device’s documented design and how it compares within its category.

Why do some acoustic grades have an asterisk?

The asterisk marks an editorial estimate. When a manufacturer publishes no decibel figure, we place the device in a noise tier based on comparable devices and grade that tier; it is not a measurement, and the review explains it.

Do you test the devices yourselves?

No. IntimPicks compares devices on manufacturer specifications and published documentation. We do not run laboratory, acoustic or battery tests, and we never present a figure as our own measurement.