Magic Wand Rechargeable vs LELO Smart Wand 2: High-Power Wand Comparison

The LELO Smart Wand 2 and the Magic Wand Rechargeable are two of the three wand massagers in our catalogue, and the two cordless ones; they represent two philosophies: a lighter, waterproof wand with a long run time on one side, the cordless version of a classic built around raw motor power on the other. This comparison is based on manufacturer specifications (LELO’s official page for the Smart Wand 2 Large), published product documentation and the mechanics of each design.

Disclosure: we may earn a commission through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Our verdicts are editorial and never paid for. How we make money.

Quick verdict

Specifications side by side

Values from manufacturer data and published product documentation. Neither LELO nor Magic Wand’s retailers publish a noise level for these two models; run times vary with intensity. Smart Wand 2 figures are for the Large version; Magic Wand figures come from authorized retailers, as the brand’s official site was not accessible.

Vibration and settings: raw power vs a wider range

Both wands use a large motor and a broad, rounded head that spreads vibration over a wide area, producing the deep, low-frequency rumble wands are known for. The Magic Wand Rechargeable is built around raw output: authorized retailers list four speeds of about 2,700 to 6,300 vibrations per minute and four patterns, and its heavier body spreads the vibration over a broad head. Both wands switch off automatically after 20 minutes of continuous use.

The Smart Wand 2 offers a wider range of settings: LELO lists ten, from low, steady vibration to pulsing patterns, at a frequency of 80 Hz, controlled from a three-button interface. Neither brand publishes comparable power figures, so we do not rank them on raw power. The Smart Wand 2 is sold in two sizes, Medium and Large; the Large version, covered here, is closest to the Magic Wand in format.

Weight and ergonomics

Weight matters with wands, which are often held at arm’s length for a while. The Magic Wand Rechargeable weighs about 595 g according to authorized retailers, against 383 g for the Smart Wand 2 Large according to LELO. The extra mass of the Magic Wand helps transmit deep vibration but can tire the hand and wrist over a long session; the Smart Wand 2 is easier to manoeuvre.

Both have a handle with the controls within reach of the thumb. LELO highlights a steadier handle on the Smart Wand 2 for stable control over the intensities; the Magic Wand relies on its soft silicone head and its larger size.

Waterproofing, hygiene and care

This is the clearest difference between the two.

• LELO Smart Wand 2: described by LELO as 100% waterproof (no IP rating stated), so the whole wand can be rinsed under running water and washed with a mild, fragrance-free soap or a toy cleaner. Make sure the charging point is dry before charging.
• Magic Wand Rechargeable: not waterproof. Clean the silicone head with a damp cloth and a mild soap or a toy cleaner, then wipe it with a clean damp cloth; never rinse it under the tap or let water reach the controls or the charging socket.
• Both: use a water-based lubricant, since silicone-based lubricants can degrade silicone heads over time, and store each wand dry, in a breathable pouch. Learn more in our guide to body-safe silicone and materials.

Acoustic discretion

Neither LELO nor Magic Wand’s authorized retailers publish a noise level for these two wands, so we cannot compare them on a figure; in our catalogue, only the mains-powered Doxy Die Cast Max states one (up to around 75 dB). Wands’ large motors produce a low-frequency hum that travels through walls and furniture more easily than the sound of compact devices. Keeping either wand off hard surfaces and using it under bedding reduces what reaches the room. For the physics behind these figures, see our noise and decibel guide.

Battery life and power supply

The Smart Wand 2 has the longer run time: up to 4 hours on a full charge for the Large version according to LELO, against around 3 hours for the Magic Wand Rechargeable according to authorized retailers. On both, higher intensities shorten the run time.

• Magic Wand Rechargeable: charges with its power adapter in about 3 hours, according to retailers, and can also run while plugged in, which removes the battery constraint at the cost of a cable. It switches off automatically after 20 minutes of continuous use, so longer sessions involve a short pause.
• LELO Smart Wand 2: charges in about 2.5 hours with the supplied USB cord (1,050 mAh battery, up to 90 days on standby) and runs cordless only. It also switches off automatically after 20 minutes.
• Both: make sure the charging socket or contacts are completely dry before charging, and use only the charger supplied by the manufacturer.

Verdict by use case

• Maximum power and broad vibration: the Magic Wand Rechargeable, built around raw output, with the option to run plugged in.
• Shower use and easy cleaning: the LELO Smart Wand 2, described as 100% waterproof, which can be rinsed under running water.
• Longest run time: the LELO Smart Wand 2, with up to 4 hours per charge against around 3 hours.
• Longer handheld sessions: the LELO Smart Wand 2, lighter (383 g against about 595 g).
• Discretion: neither is a discreet device; LELO publishes no noise level for the Smart Wand 2, so see our quiet devices ranking if a stated figure matters.

Where they rank

In our wand ranking, the LELO Smart Wand 2 is first (4.5/5), the mains-powered Doxy Die Cast Max Plug-in second (4.4/5) and the Magic Wand Rechargeable third (4.2/5): the Magic Wand is built around a broad head and deep vibration, but its lack of waterproofing, shorter run time and heavier body weigh against it. For more compact alternatives, see our best picks by category.

Read the full reviews

• LELO Smart Wand 2 review: design, materials, acoustics and care
• Magic Wand Rechargeable review: design, materials, acoustics and care

Frequently asked questions

This comparison provides general information and is not medical advice. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for use, cleaning and charging.